It has been argued by some that, “no society produces zero waste” (Pellow, 2007). Others romanticize native peoples as living in harmony with the earth and creating no waste or alterations to the environment. Whatever the historical cases may be, the waste currently produced by human civilizations is a problem with which modern society must grapple. In addition to its existence the problem of human generated waste is compounded by population growth; more people, means more consumption and more waste produced. The problem is further inflamed by habits of over-consumption that have become an epidemic in the developed world. As stated by Pellow in his book Resisting Global Toxics: Transnational Movements for Environmental Justice, “19% of the worlds waste is produced by the US which only accounts for 5% of the worlds populations”. The United States is of particular concern. The United States alone generated over 250 million tons of waste in 2007, the equivalent of approximately 4.6 pounds per capita per day (EPA, 2007). In addition to the sheer amount of trash generated by Americans it is frightening to examine the trends that have emerged in their life styles. Americans are increasingly living throw away lives producing 166 millions more tons of trash per year than they were less than a century ago (EPA, 2007). However, the US is not the only guilty party. Other garbage gluttons include but are not limited to: Canadians who produced an average of 5.29 pounds per capita per day in 2002 (Bonam, Sawyer, Smith, & Thompson, 2007), the UK generating and average of 330 million tons yearly(Baldcok, 2008), France with an average waste out put of 545 kg/capita/year (Griffiths & Williams, 2005), Germany’s per capita yearly waste generation of 610 kg (Griffiths, 2005), and Japan weights in at 412 kg/capita/year of waste (Griffiths, 2005). At any rate as global citizens we are accumulating more waste then we ever have in the past and we must find a way to deal with it.
Dumping and burning have proven to be the global fall backs for waste management. David Pellow, author of Resisting Global Toxics: Transnational Movements for Environmental Justice suggests, “Since human societies first produced waste streams, we have buried our trash, and since the discovery of fire, we have burned our waste.” Yearly the US landfills over half of its waste; in 2007 this accounted for 137 million tons (EPA, 2007). In addition to landfilling the US sends approximately 13% or 32 million tons of its waste to incinerators (EPA, 2007). While these techniques are the most widely used they are not with out costs.
Waste incinerators have particularly high social and health costs. Incinerators are commonly associated with lower air quality and foul odors in near by areas. This can combined with the fact that incinerator installment in communities yield minimal economic results (Pellow, 2007) reduce the desirability and market value of housing in areas where incinerators are sited. However, odors and lack of economic growth are the least of the problems that incinerators bring with them. When incinerators run they burn waste creating two byproducts, ash and smoke. Both of these byproducts have proven to have negative impacts on humans and other biotics. Ash when dumped disrupts soils PH levels as it is a very basic material. The other byproduct of incinerators, smoke, often contains Dioxin a chemical that is far more toxic than DDT (Pellow, 2007). Incineration also increases the particulate pollution in the air which is associated with increased incidents of asthma attacks, obstructive pulmonary disease and ear nose and throat infections (Anthony & Thompson, 2005) to name a few. In addition the presence of incinerators puts residents in near by areas at higher rates of exposure to carcinogens. In Chester, a suburb of Philidelphia where much of the Municipal Solid waste for the city is incinerated, citizens were victim to lung cancer at a rate 60% higher than the national average (Pellow, 2007). In addition to being carcinogenic materials put out by waste incinerators, “can cause immune changes, lung and liver damage, retarded cognitive and motor development, lowered birth weight and lowered growth rate”(Anthony & Thompson, 2005). Due to the mounting evidence that incinerators do more harm than good there have been many local movements around the globe to put an end to the incineration of waste. The US has been fairly progressive witnessing the closing of 98% of its incinerators since 1988 (Pellow, 2007). However, the Philippines are by far the most progressive passing a governmental ban on the construction of new incinerators (Pellow, 2007). Many of these campaigns have grown from community outrage at the health risks that incinerators induce. However, a good portion of campaigns have NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard) roots. Thus they are not against incinerators, but instead against incineration in the back yards of those doing the campaigning. This may prove to be a fatal flaw as it ignores the fact that something must be done with the waste. If not by incinerators in their back yards then how and where will waste be handled?
One of the most common answers is landfilling. However, landfills present their own set of conundrums apart from incinerators. The most basic of problems created by landfills are loss of land for food production and housing, loss of energy, and loss of material resources (Bonam et al., 2007). However, to understand the problems that come with landfills we must examine what they are. Landfills are exactly what they sound like, holes dug in the ground filled with garbage that is often mounded up above the hole itself. While regulations in the United States require that landfills be lined to prevent the leaching of toxins, many landfills were constructed before such regulations were put in place and remain unlined. In addition to these grandfathered in landfills there are yet other landfills that while originally adequately lined now have degraded so that the linings are ineffective and leak. This puts residence near landfills at risk of water and soil contamination. In addition to the constant risk of water contamination residents also contend with lower air quality due to the odor of decaying materials in the landfills. The issues of water, air, and soil pollution (Bronam et al. 2007) are the most pressing to those who reside near landfill facilities. As well, residents must deal with the propensity of pests to cluster near landfills as they are attracted by the scavenging possibilities.
The environmental and health risks created by landfills are very notable problems. However they are not the only problems, there may be more threatening problems lurking in the back ground. In recent years there has been a lot of buzz about global climate change and at this point a majority of scientists are in agreement that it does exist and is a real problem. The maid contributors to global climate change are green house gasses. The most well know of which is CO2 or carbon dioxide. However, there are much more notorious gases. One such gas is methane; it is approximately 21 times more potent in terms of global warming than is CO2 (Bonam et al. 2007). Along with the aforementioned problems that landfills produce they also produce gasses made of up to 65% methane (Bonam et al. 2007). In this way landfills not only permanently reduce the amount of useable land, create water and air pollution harmful to humans, but also threaten the global community with climate instability.
Landfills present one final problem, they fill up and thus one landfill is not an indefinite solution to the waste generated by humans. This problem is appearing in a deceptive manner across the United States; the number of landfills open to dumping diminishes yearly (Pellow, 2007). This can be erroneously attributed lack of need, however as previously discussed the volume of waste generated is growing. The practice of landfilling and incineration are clearly not with out risks and costs.
References:
Anthony, H., & Thompson, J. (2005). BSEM Report: The health effects of waste
incinerators. Journal of Nutritional &Environmental Medicine, 15 (2/3). 115-156.
Baldock, C. The Environment Agency of the UK. (2008). The Environment Agency: Waste. http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/subjects/waste/?lang=_e Date Accessed: November 15, 2008
Bonam, R., Sawyer, J., Smith, S., & Thompson, S. (2007, March). Will Waste Diversion make a Difference in Greenhouse Gas Emissions? An Analysis of Methane Generation in Canadian Landfills. Proceedings of the International Conference on Waste Technologies and Management. Retrieved November 11, 2008 from Environment Complete Database.
Griffiths, T., & Williams, K. (2005). Thermal Treatment Options. Earthscan. http://www.earthscan.co.uk/news/printablearticle.asp?sp=&v=5&UAN=456
Pellow, D.N. (2007). Resisting Global Toxics: Transnational movements of environmental justice. Cambridge, The MIT Press.
United Sates Environmental Protection Agency. (2008). Waste-Resource Conservation Reduce, Reuse, Recycle- Composting. http://www.epa.gov/osw/conserv/rrr/composting/indext.htm.composting/indext.htm. Retrieved October 5, 2008.
United States Environmental Protection Agency. (2008). Solid Waste in New England. http://www.epa.gov/ne/composting/index/htm Retrieved October 5, 2008.
United Sates Environmental Protection Agency. (2008). Summary of the EPA Municipal Solid Waste Program. http://www.epa/gov/reg3wcmd/solidwastesummary.htm. Retrieved November 15, 2008.
United Sates Environmental Protection Agency. (2007). Municipal Solid Waste generation, Recycling, and Disposal in the United States: Facts and Figures for 2007. http://www.epa/gov/osw/nohaz/municipal/pubs/msw07-fs.pdf. Retrieved November 15, 2008.
Friday, November 21, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment